Breakingviews on Twitter
Search League Tables

Saturday, 28 May 2016

In a China shop

Japan tensions rewrite China shopping lists

China’s buying habits have taken on an air of the patriotic, at least where Japan is concerned. As tensions rose last year over who owns a group of remote islands, sales of Japanese cars and arrivals of Chinese tourists showed a marked slowdown. Even Chinese acquisitions of Japanese companies fell in the last quarter of 2012.

Consumer patriotism tends to be pragmatic. In China, buyers kept away from Japanese brands when the row over the Diaoyu Islands, as it calls them, spilled into the street. But for low-cost or inconspicuous items, they soon went back to buying products they liked. Japanese fashion retailer Uniqlo, which shuttered some stores during the protests, still plans to open its biggest store so far in Shanghai this year.

More conspicuous investments were hit harder. Japanese auto companies saw a sharp drop in China sales immediately after the protests, when some owners became targets for angry mobs. But even then, emotions fade. Honda sales in China are now returning to growth, and Toyota’s sales grew 24 percent in January, year on year, having fallen 17 percent in December. Japan may have seen 34 percent fewer Chinese tourists in December, according to projections from the Japan National Tourism Organization, but that might reflect fears of geopolitical risk as much as patriotism.

It’s companies whose behaviour may have changed most. Chinese acquisitions of Japanese companies fell by 93 percent year on year to $9 million in the final quarter of 2012. The feeling was mutual. Japanese acquisitions of Chinese companies fell by as much as 72 percent year on year in the three months ending December 2012.

Executives are susceptible to groupthink and few want to go against the political grain. In China, buying companies overseas also means getting the approval of various regulators.

The island spat is far from resolved. Japan’s new Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has taken a robust tone, complaining on Feb. 5 about “continued provocations” against the country’s sovereignty. Such remarks have helped to transform the longstanding squabble into a significant perceived risk for business. It may take executives rather longer than consumers to forgive, or at least forget.

Have your say

To have your say, you have to be signed in

Related images

Context News

The value of acquisitions in Japan by Chinese companies fell 93 percent, year on year, to $9 million in the quarter ending Dec. 31, 2012, following protests in Chinese cities over a group of contested islands. Japanese M&A into China fell by 72 percent year on year to $24 million, according to data from Thomson Reuters. In September 2012, the month protests broke out, Japanese M&A in China totalled $720 million, ten times larger than a year earlier.

The number of visitors from China to Japan increased by 8.1 percent in September, year on year, but fell by 34 percent in October, according to the Japan National Tourism Organization. Preliminary figures suggested that numbers could decline by as much as 43 percent in November and 34 percent in December.

The owner of clothing retailer Uniqlo, said sales in China fell 25 percent in September, year on year. The company said it would not alter its expansion plans in China and expects to open the world’s largest Uniqlo branch in Shanghai in April 2013.

Honda Motor Co said sales in China fell 40.5 percent year on year in September, but grew 22 percent in January. Toyota Motor Corp said sales in China fell 49 percent year on year in September, while sales fell 17 percent in December, before growing by 24 percent year on year in January.

Anti-Japan riots in China over the islands, which in China are called Diaoyu and in Japan are called Senkaku, peaked in the week beginning Sept. 23.

(Launches in a new window)