We have updated our Terms of Use.
Please read our new Privacy Statement before continuing.

Better than war

25 November 2013 By Una Galani

Iran’s nuclear deal offers the world a ray of hope. It won’t be easy to turn the agreement to curb Tehran’s nuclear activities from a six-month accord into a lasting solution that assures the world the country’s nuclear programme is peaceful. But the resulting diplomatic goodwill should make it harder to go backwards.

The initial deal with six world powers effectively lengthens the time it would take for Iran to build a bomb. In return, Tehran gets limited relief from sanctions worth up to $7 billion. Senior U.S. administration officials estimate that is equivalent to 20 percent of Iran’s budget deficit, or 23 percent of the oil revenues it would lose over the six months.

It’s a good first step which helps ease geopolitical risk in the red hot Middle East. The alternative was an unraveling of the international sanctions coalition and possibly even a Western-led war with huge costs and unknown political consequences. As long as the accord holds, that scenario – and the risk of unilateral military action by Israel – is greatly reduced. Even though the supply of Iranian crude won’t change for now, improved sentiment should push oil prices back down from current levels over $108 per barrel.

A lasting deal would enable a full reintegration of Shi’ite-led Iran back into the global economy, with profound consequences. Biting energy and financial sanctions could start to unwind. The eventual return of 1.5 million barrels per day of lost Iranian crude would change the dynamics of the oil market, even if other oil producers responded by cutting production. An influx of foreign investment would strengthen the region’s second biggest economy and help counterbalance the immense regional power of the Sunni monarchies led by Saudi Arabia.

But there are plenty of obstacles to overcome first. Any final deal will face domestic political resistance. The two sides need to agree on whether the current framework represents a floor or a ceiling to Iran’s nuclear activities, warns Barclays. Eurasia Group ascribes only a 60 percent chance of the current agreement turning into a lasting one. Still, it was hard to imagine such a rapprochement just six months ago. That alone is a reason to be hopeful.


Email a friend

Please complete the form below.

Required fields *


(Separate multiple email addresses with commas)