No brainer

29 October 2012 By Reynolds Holding Follow @holdingren

The nation exploited fuzzy language to stiff debt-swap holdouts. As Breakingviews predicted, a U.S. court ordered it to pay up, saying a promise to treat creditors equally is plenty clear. Rather than spark market chaos, the ruling sends the message that deal terms have teeth.

This content is for Subscribers only

Context News

The U.S. Court of Appeals in New York on Oct. 26 upheld an order blocking Argentina from paying bondholders without also paying NML Capital, an affiliate of New York-based hedge fund Elliott Associates, and other investors in defaulted bonds.

The case involves Argentina’s 2005 offer to exchange $95 billion in defaulted debt for new bonds worth 30 cents on the dollar. NML and other holders of about $20 billion of the debt rejected the offer, and in 2010 NML spurned a second restructuring that exchanged $12.9 billion of the remaining $20 billion for new bonds. About 92 percent of the original debt has been swapped out. Argentina has not made payments on the NML bonds since 2001.

The three-judge appellate panel ruled that Argentina’s official actions, including a law prohibiting payment on the hedge fund’s debt, violated the bonds’ so-called pari passu provision, which requires equal treatment for all of the debt.

Email a friend

Please complete the form below.

Required fields *