Getting in tune

21 January 2015 By Reynolds Holding Follow @holdingren

A commissioner at the watchdog raised the stakes by calling the university’s shareholder-rights advocates deceptive. Dozens of professors howled, while former SEC lawyers jumped to the official’s defense. Catty tone aside, it’s a corporate governance debate that needs to happen.

This content is for Subscribers only

Context News

A Boston University law professor on Jan. 20 joined a public dispute over Harvard Law School’s Shareholder Rights Project, whose advocacy for certain corporate governance practices has been called deceptive and possibly illegal by a senior U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission official and others.

Boston’s Tamar Frankel said SEC Commissioner Daniel Gallagher’s accusations against the program were inappropriate and perhaps unethical for a sitting official.

At issue is a December 2014 research paper by Gallagher and Stanford University’s Joseph Grundfest, a former SEC commissioner. The paper suggested the agency could sue Harvard for not disclosing evidence against a governance measure the Shareholder Rights Project advocates: making directors face elections annually rather than every two or three years.

The Harvard project advises activist investors and helps them draw up resolutions calling for the elimination of so-called staggered boards, which make it harder to replace a majority of directors at one time. Gallagher and Grundfest’s paper said proposals using the project’s wording were so one-sided that they could be “false and misleading.”

A group of 34 senior law professors called the paper’s charges “deeply flawed” and urged the authors to withdraw their accusations.

Context News

Boston’s Tamar Frankel said SEC Commissioner Daniel Gallagher’s accusations against the program were inappropriate and perhaps unethical for a sitting official.

A group of 34 senior law professors called the paper’s charges “deeply flawed” and urged the authors to withdraw their accusations.

Email a friend

Please complete the form below.

Required fields *