Breakingviews on Twitter
Search League Tables

Thursday, 26 May 2016

Oil over?

U.S. oil price rise should fuel export ban’s fall

The price of American oil has finally caught up with globally traded Brent crude, thanks to U.S. pipeline and railway improvements. Now drillers need to be allowed to ship their product overseas. With supply surging, they’ll quickly outgrow the limits of a domestic market.

For nearly three years U.S. oil fetched less than the global market price. The gap was widest in October 2011, when America’s West Texas Intermediate sold for just $87 a barrel, compared with $114 for Brent.

Since the two types of crude are essentially of equal quality, the price difference inflicted a substantial penalty on American drillers while giving their customers artificially low costs. The main culprit was a pipeline network that couldn’t accommodate a 40 percent surge in U.S. crude output since 2008.

That problem has been solved, at least temporarily. Pipeline capacity has increased, while rail networks have become more efficient at delivering oil where it’s needed. As a result, the price gap briefly closed on July 19.

There are, however, risks ahead. American oil output is expanding at breakneck speed, with Citigroup anticipating a million-barrel per day increase this year, a greater amount than in any other country. That could leave U.S. refiners with more light sweet crude than they can process, prompting another drop in prices.

One solution would be to lift the U.S. Mineral Leasing Act’s almost century-long ban on American crude exports. Since the law was enacted in 1920, a special license has been required for overseas shipments of even small amounts of oil. Last year, an average of just 52,000 barrels a day was sent abroad. Daily imports, on the other hand, totaled close to 8 million barrels. Freeing up exports would make it easier to meet global demand for American crude while relieving U.S. drillers from the burden of peddling their product for below-market prices.

The plan could provoke resistance from certain members of Congress and others who argue that America should preserve its valuable oil supplies. But that would risk suppressing U.S. crude prices and slowing the growth of one of the nation’s most important industries.

Have your say

To have your say, you have to be signed in

Context News

The prices of Brent crude and America’s West Texas Intermediate oil hit parity on July 19. As recently as March 6, WTI traded at a $20 discount per barrel to Brent.

The gap between the two benchmark oil prices was widest on October 14, 2011, when WTI traded at $86.94 a barrel and Brent at $114.20, a $27.26 difference, according to Thomson Reuters.

On July 22, Brent crude traded at $108 a barrel, compared with $107 for WTI.

(Launches in a new window)